• Psychool
  • Posts
  • Why “I Would Never Do That” Is Usually a Lie We Tell Ourselves

Why “I Would Never Do That” Is Usually a Lie We Tell Ourselves

Why “I Would Never Do That” Is Usually a Lie We Tell Ourselves

Most people believe they are good.

Not in a heroic sense, but in a quiet, assumed way. The kind of goodness that doesn’t need proof because it feels obvious. I wouldn’t join a cruel crowd. I wouldn’t laugh at someone’s humiliation. I wouldn’t stay silent if something terrible was happening.

That belief is comforting. It protects our identity. It allows us to believe cruelty belongs to other people.

Psychology tells a different story — one that is far more unsettling. The line between “them” and “us” is thinner than we want to admit, and most human cruelty doesn’t come from evil intent, but from ordinary people responding to ordinary situations.

🧪 RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Try These Popular Tests

🖤Dark Triad Assessment

Explore shadow traits

Take →
💕Attachment Avoidance Test

Understand your relationship patterns

Take →
🪞Narcissistic Personality Inventory (NPI)

Measure narcissistic traits

Take →
😰Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI)

Assess anxiety levels

Take →
🌧️Depression Screening (PHQ-9)

Screen for depression

Take →
THE INSIGHTS
#1

The Myth of the “Good Person”

We like to believe morality is a stable trait — something you either have or don’t. In reality, moral behavior is highly dependent on context. Good people do good things, but they also do nothing, stay silent, and follow crowds when situations make it easier to disengage than to act.

#2

How Psychological Distance Protects Our Self-Image

When we witness cruelty, our first instinct is separation. I am not like them. This mental distance shields us from guilt, but it also prevents accountability. The further we push ourselves from uncomfortable behavior, the less prepared we are to recognize it in ourselves.

#3

When Responsibility Quietly Disappears

In group settings, responsibility doesn’t feel shared — it feels diluted. Each person assumes someone else will intervene. Psychologists call this diffusion of responsibility, and it is one of the most powerful reasons people fail to act when action matters most.

#4

Losing Yourself Inside the Crowd

Anonymity changes behavior. In crowds or online spaces, people experience deindividuation — a loss of personal identity. Moral restraint weakens when no one is watching you, only the group.

#5

Why Watching Can Feel Easier Than Helping

Observation requires less courage than intervention. Watching allows emotional distance, while helping demands risk. Over time, repeated observation without action dulls empathy and makes indifference feel normal.

#6

The Psychology of Moral Disengagement

To preserve our self-image, we justify inaction. It’s not that serious. They brought it on themselves. It’s not my responsibility. These small justifications allow harm to continue without us feeling responsible for it.

#7

Why “I Would Never Do That” Feels So Convincing

Believing we are immune to cruelty gives us psychological comfort. It replaces vigilance with certainty. The problem is not that people believe they are good — it’s that certainty makes us stop paying attention.

#8

The Moments That Actually Reveal Character

Character isn’t revealed in imagined heroic moments. It appears in quiet, uncomfortable choices — when speaking up would cost social approval, when silence feels safer, when cruelty is subtle and socially accepted.

#9

What Happens When We Admit Our Vulnerability to Cruelty

Acknowledging our susceptibility doesn’t make us worse people — it makes us more responsible ones. Awareness restores choice. Humility restores empathy.

#10

The Lie That Allows Cruelty to Survive

The most dangerous lie isn’t “I am cruel.”

It’s “I could never be.”

Cruelty thrives not on hatred, but on certainty, silence, and the belief that morality is automatic. It isn’t. It’s a choice — one we must keep making, especially when it’s uncomfortable.

🔓 EXCLUSIVE FOR PREMIUM

Unlock Deeper Psychology Insights

Get unlimited access to 1000+ psychology tests, detailed AI-powered reports, and personalized analysis.

Upgrade to Premium →
Explore All Tests →

Recommended Reading

Reply

or to participate.